Senator Patty
Murray, Democrat of Washington State, is “strongly” opposing the
confirmation of Sam Clovis, Trump’s nominee to be
USDA chief scientist. Murray based her
opposition on concerns that Washington is vulnerable to the dangers of
climate change, and need government officials who respect the science,
not “an adamant climate change denier” with a “deeply disturbing record
of racist, homophobic, and sexist comments.”
Murray expressed her opposition in a letter to a constituent obtained by
Hill Heat.
Murray is the sixth senator to publicly oppose the nominee, who rejected
the science of climate change, promoted the conspiracy theory that
Barack Obama was not born in the United States, and argued that
homosexuality is a choice.
A growing coalition of environmental, science, and sustainable farming
organizations oppose
Clovis.
Thank you for contacting me with regard to Dr. Sam Clovis, President
Donald J. Trump’s nominee to be the Under Secretary for Research,
Education, and Economics and chief scientist for the U.S. Department
of Agriculture (USDA). I appreciate hearing from you.
The responsibility to evaluate and vote upon nominees is one of my
most important duties as your senator. I evaluate each individual that
a president submits to the Senate based upon their record and
experience to make sure they meet my long-held standards regarding
ethics, honesty, and substantive experience in fields related to the
job for which they are nominated. Whether in committee or on the
Senate floor, I ask tough questions about how each nominee plans to
move our country forward, to make it more just and inclusive, and to
fight for the middle class and working families.
President Trump promised to “drain the swamp,” but with his choices of
many Cabinet nominees and other officials, he has repeatedly broken
that promise. So many of his nominees have been mired in shocking
conflicts of interest or simply have not had the basic experience
necessary for the positions they seek to fill. President Trump has
continued to break that promise with the nomination of Dr. Clovis, who
lacks any relevant experience for the position and is unfit to serve
in any office of public service due to his history of racist and
outrageous public comments. The president has again put campaign
politics before basic competence by selecting Clovis, who served as
one his senior campaign advisors, over individuals with knowledge and
experience related to USDA, to agriculture
in general, and to the agricultural research that is so important to
Washington state.
The 2008 Farm Bill added the responsibility of chief scientist to the
Under Secretary’s role, expanding the position’s duties and including
the responsibility to lead scientific evaluation of evidence and data
in order to inform policymaking. By law, this individual must be a
scientist, and Dr. Clovis is not. He holds degrees in political
science, business, and public administration, but appears to have no
actual science background and has never worked in the agricultural
economy. Accordingly, he is unable to fulfill the requirements of the
Farm Bill and is unqualified for this role. I am also concerned by
Clovis’ continued rejection of clear science, as he remains an adamant
climate change denier. Climate change is real, and we can no longer
pretend it is not. It is impacting families, workers, families, and
business in Washington state and across the country. In Washington
state, the realities of climate change have led to shrinking glaciers
on Mt. Rainier, more intense and devastating wildfires, the loss of
crops, reduced yields, and the destruction of wildlife habitats.
USDA’s chief scientist must not be a person
who rejects science or who questions the importance of crop insurance
programs that are so important to our state, as Clovis has.
In addition to clearly lacking appropriate experience and training for
the role, Clovis has a deeply disturbing record of racist, homophobic,
and sexist comments that do not represent the values of Washington
state and are unacceptable for any individual to make, let alone
someone seeking a public office. His hateful and divisive words have
no place in our diverse nation. Now more than ever, and in the wake of
events like the tragedy in Charlottesville, we cannot permit hatred
and bigotry to go unchallenged anywhere. Individuals who hold such
views have no place being in positions of public trust.
I have been proud to lead the fight against President Trump’s
unqualified nominees, and I will keep up that fight for as long as it
takes. If and when Dr. Sam Clovis’ nomination for the Under Secretary
of Research, Education, and Economics comes before the full Senate, I
will strongly oppose him. The chief scientist role at
USDA, which drives the agricultural research
that is vital to maintaining Washington state’s edge in a global
agricultural marketplace, must be filled by a competent professional
who believes in science and in creating a sustainable future for all —
regardless of race, gender, or sexual orientation.
Again, thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts with me,
and please know that I will keep them in mind. If you would like to
know more about my work in the Senate, please feel free to sing up for
updates at http://murray.senate.gov/updates.
Sincerely,
Patty Murray
United States Senator