Susan Molinari at a Google/Elle/Center for American Progress event
January 19, 2013
A review of the “don’t be evil” Internet giant Google’s stance toward
climate change and green policy finds a significant shift to the right
in recent years, following the Tea Party surge election and the collapse
of mandatory climate legislation in 2010.
Since 2012, Google’s policy division has been run by former Republican
representative Susan Molinari, a long-time corporate
lobbyist.
Molinari, whose personal
contributions
are exclusively to Republicans, has led the Google Washington DC office
to host fundraisers exclusively for Republican
senators,
including Sens. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), John Thune (R-S.D.), John Barrasso
(R-Wyo.), and Rand Paul (R-Ky.), according to the Sunlight Foundation’s
Political Party Time database. Under Molinari’s direction, Google also
supports
climate-denial shops such as the Competitive Enterprise Institute,
Heritage Foundation, and the American Conservative Union.
Google’s fundraiser for Sen. Inhofe in July sparked controversy and
protest,
and the membership in ALEC raised a new round of
criticism
from industry
press
and Google
users.
Google’s political support for opponents of its green agenda appears to
be part of a retreat from its serious climate-policy agenda of a few
years ago.
At a recent
forum
on the Internet industry’s support for green energy, Facebook and Google
representatives could not explain why their companies are members of a
powerful lobbying organization that opposes that mission. This year,
Google and Facebook became
members
of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a nationwide
lobbying group that links corporations and conservative foundations with
Republican legislators at the state level. When asked by Hill Heat,
Facebook’s Bill Weihl replied with reference to other Facebook partners,
including Businesses for Social Responsibility (BSR), the World
Resources Institute (WRI), and the World Wildlife Fund (WWF):
We’re not an advocacy or a single-issue organization. We’re a company.
We are members of many different organizations, that one included. We
don’t necessarily agree with everything that these organizations says
and certainly individual employees may not, but we do an enormous
amount of good and we’re really proud of the work we’ve done through
other organizations. We work with Greenpeace,
BSR, WRI, WWF, and
etcetera.
Watch:
“It’s certainly not because we’re trying to oppose renewable energy
legislation,” Weihl concluded, when asked why Facebook is a member of
ALEC.
Weihl had earlier noted that Facebook has the explicit goal of being 25%
powered by renewable energy by 2015, after which it will set another
benchmark. ALEC is working to roll back
renewable power standards that support Facebook’s targets.
“The DNA of Google isn’t just about being an
environmental steward,” Google’s Gary Demasi said during the panel about
climate change. “It’s a basic fundamental issue for the company.”
Like Weihl, Demasi couldn’t explain why Google was a member of
ALEC, though he expressed discomfort with the
company’s action.
“I would say the same as Bill [Weihl],” Demasi told this reporter when
asked why Google supports ALEC. Although he
may not be happy with every decision the company makes and doesn’t
control the policy arm of Google, Demasi said, “we’re part of policy
discussions.”
ALEC’s corporate
board
is dominated by tobacco and fossil-fuel interests, including Altria,
Exxon Mobil, Peabody Energy, and Koch Industries. In its model
legislation and policy briefs, ALEC questions
the science of climate change and opposes renewable energy standards,
regulation of greenhouse pollution, and other climate
initiatives.
Google’s policy division is run by former Republican representative
Susan Molinari, whose arrival in 2012 marked a rightward
shift
in Google’s approach to climate policy.
The forum, “Greening the
Internet,”
was hosted by the environmental organization Greenpeace at the San
Francisco Exploratorium. Greenpeace is simultaneously
challenging
the
ALEC
agenda, calling
out
companies like Google for supporting the politics of climate denial, and
encouraging internet companies to “clean the
cloud.”
Greenpeace’s “Cool IT” rankings take political
advocacy
as a major concern; in 2012 Google had the top score among all tech
companies in part because companies such as Microsoft and AT&T were
members of ALEC.
The panelists, from Google, Facebook, Rackspace, Box, and
NREL, explained why their companies have set
the goal of having their data centers be powered entirely by renewable
energy.
Box’s Andy Broer made the moral case for acting to reduce climate
pollution.
“I’ve got kids,” he said. “We’re stewards here. We need to make certain
what we’re doing today doesn’t ruin the future.”